Fans have figured out WHO really made the “showmance” comment on tonight’s episode of Love Island: All stars.
Following an intense reunion with ex Harriett and an awkward catch-up with current couple Elma, Ronnie became aware people were accusing him of a “showmance.”
After speaking with the girls and revealing Ronnie had asked her three times to be his girlfriend, Harriett has a follow up chat with Ronnie.

Love Island All Stars SR2 Ep12: on ITV2 and ITVX
Pictured: RONNIE, HARRIETT.
Speaking to her ex, Harriett asked: “Did you say it was a showmance? cause every single girl there has said you said it.”
Ronnie swiftly replied: “I haven’t said it was a showmance once, not to any of those girls.”
Calling out to the girls, Ronnie asked: “Girls, when have I once said to you, it was a showmance with me and Harriett.”
In a back and forth conversation with no clear resolution, Kaz replied: “I heard you say it, when were we standing playing the red flag game, you said you ‘no that’s a showmance thing.”

Love Island All Stars SR2 Ep12: on ITV2 and ITVX
Pictured: RONNIE, ELMA.
Many rewinded previous episodes, figuring out it was Gabby who had brought up the idea of a “showmance” to Marcel.
During the red flags game, Gabby had said to Marcel: “You did tell the girl we were a showmance.”
Fans were shook at the argument, as many ran to X formally known as Twitter to try and figure out what happened.

Love Island All Stars SR2 Ep12: on ITV2 and ITVX
Pictured: RONNIE.
One wrote: “I can’t wait for movie night. ROLL THE TAPES OF GABI SAYING MARCEL CALLED HER A SHOWMANCE NOT RONNIE SAYING IT ABOUT HARRIET.”
Another wrote: “The only time the word “showmance” came out in episode one and that was by Gabi saying it about Marcel.”
A third wrote: “he never ever said it was a showmance,” alongside a clip from the episode.
Another viewer wrote: “The girls really got it confused with who said it, Marcel was the one who said his relationship with Gabby was a showmance.”
I can’t wait for movie night. ROLL THE TAPES OF GABI SAYING MARCEL CALLED HER A SHOWMANCE NOT RONNIE SAYING IT ABOUT HARRIET #loveisland #loveislandallstars #allstars pic.twitter.com/2ZLFWdXiwh
— mrs branning (@Margjacquieline) January 24, 2025
The only time the word “showmance” came out in episode one and that was by Gabi saying it about Marcel #LoveIsland #LoveIslandAllStars pic.twitter.com/JN3H0rGtv2
— Lᴀ♡ (@MissLA23_) January 24, 2025
he never ever said it was a showmance #LoveIsland #AllStars #LoveIslandAllStars https://t.co/5ChnokvW4V pic.twitter.com/9NYmA0XsaO
— Lᴀ♡ (@MissLA23_) January 24, 2025
The girls really got it confused with who said it, Marcel was the one who said his relationship with Gabby was a showmance😭#LoveIsland pic.twitter.com/kZ8iyjW649
— Sana (@sanaravishing) January 24, 2025